| Win | Peter Queally | Bellator 285: Henderson vs. Queally | 23 September 2022 | Decision decision |
| Win | Islam Mamedov | Bellator 273: Bader vs. Moldavsky | 29 January 2022 | Decision decision |
| Loss | Brent Primus | Bellator 268: Nemkov vs. Anglickas | 16 October 2021 | Decision decision |
| Loss | Jason Jackson | Bellator 253: Caldwell vs. McKee | 19 November 2020 | Decision decision |
| Win | Myles Jury | Bellator 227: Bellator Dublin | 28 September 2019 | Decision decision |
| Win | Adam Piccolotti | Bellator 220: MacDonald vs. Fitch | 27 April 2019 | Decision decision |
| Win | Saad Awad | Bellator 208: Fedor vs. Sonnen | 13 October 2018 | Decision decision |
| Loss | Patricky Freire | Bellator 183: Henderson vs. Pitbull | 23 September 2017 | Decision decision |
| Loss | Michael Chandler | Bellator 165: Chandler vs. Henderson | 19 November 2016 | Decision decision |
| Loss | Andrey Koreshkov | Bellator 153: Koreshkov vs. Henderson | 22 April 2016 | Decision decision |
| Win | Jorge Masvidal | UFC Fight Night 79: Henderson vs. Masvidal | 28 November 2015 | Decision decision |
| Loss | Donald Cerrone | UFC Fight Night 59: McGregor vs. Siver | 18 January 2015 | Decision decision |
| Win | Josh Thomson | UFC on Fox 10: Henderson vs. Thomson | 25 January 2014 | Decision decision |
| Win | Gilbert Melendez | UFC on Fox 7: Henderson vs. Melendez | 20 April 2013 | Decision decision |
| Win | Nate Diaz | UFC on Fox 5: Henderson vs. Diaz | 8 December 2012 | Decision decision |
| Win | Frankie Edgar | UFC 150: Henderson vs. Edgar II | 11 August 2012 | Decision decision |
| Win | Frankie Edgar | UFC 144: Edgar vs. Henderson | 26 February 2012 | Decision decision |
| Win | Clay Guida | UFC on Fox 1: Velasquez vs. Dos Santos | 12 November 2011 | Decision decision |
| Win | Jim Miller | UFC Live: Hardy vs. Lytle | 14 August 2011 | Decision decision |
| Win | Mark Bocek | UFC 129: St-Pierre vs. Shields | 30 April 2011 | Decision decision |
| Loss | Anthony Pettis | WEC 53: Henderson vs. Pettis | 16 December 2010 | Decision decision |
| Win | Donald Cerrone | WEC 43: Cerrone vs. Henderson | 10 October 2009 | Decision decision |