| Loss | Reinier de Ridder | UFC on ABC 9: Whittaker vs. de Ridder | 26 July 2025 | Decision - Split → |
| Win | Paulo Costa | UFC 298: Volkanovski vs. Topuria | 17 February 2024 | Decision - Unanimous → |
| Win | Marvin Vettori | UFC on ESPN+ 67: Gane vs. Tuivasa | 3 September 2022 | Decision - Unanimous → |
| Loss | Israel Adesanya | UFC 271: Adesanya vs. Whittaker 2 | 12 February 2022 | Decision - Unanimous → |
| Win | Kelvin Gastelum | UFC on ESPN 22: Whittaker vs. Gastelum | 17 April 2021 | Decision - Unanimous → |
| Win | Jared Cannonier | UFC 254: Khabib vs. Gaethje | 24 October 2020 | Decision - Unanimous → |
| Win | Darren Till | UFC on ESPN 14: Whittaker vs. Till | 26 July 2020 | Decision - Unanimous → |
| Win | Yoel Romero | UFC 225: Whittaker vs. Romero 2 | 9 June 2018 | Decision - Split → |
| Win | Yoel Romero | UFC 213: Romero vs. Whittaker | 8 July 2017 | Decision - Unanimous → |
| Win | Rafael Natal | UFC 197: Jones vs. Saint Preux | 23 April 2016 | Decision - Unanimous → |
| Win | Uriah Hall | UFC 193: Rousey vs. Holm | 15 November 2015 | Decision - Unanimous → |
| Win | Mike Rhodes | UFC Fight Night 43: Te Huna vs. Marquardt | 28 June 2014 | Decision - Unanimous → |
| Loss | Court McGee | UFN 27: Condit vs. Kampmann 2 | 28 August 2013 | Decision - Split → |
| Win | Brad Scott | UFC on FX 6: Sotiropoulos vs. Pearson | 15 December 2012 | Decision - Unanimous → |